Diamond Drill
Blog · Drilling and geotechnics

When SPT Is Not Enough: CPT, DPSH and Rotary Coring

The SPT is the most widely used in-situ test in the world, but it does not answer every question. Knowing when to add or replace it makes an investigation more useful and often cheaper.

Where SPT falls short

  • Soft soils. In very soft clays and loose silts the blow count is low and poorly resolved.
  • Thin layers. One reading per meter can miss thin weak layers.
  • Gravel, cobbles and boulders. Coarse particles distort the N-value.
  • Rock. The test cannot characterize intact rock or its fracturing.
  • Repeatability. Hammer energy varies between systems and operators.

The main alternatives

MethodWhat it givesBest forLimits
CPT / CPTuContinuous profile of tip resistance, sleeve friction and often pore pressureSoft to medium soils, layeringCannot penetrate dense gravel or rock; no physical sample
DPSHContinuous blow count profileQuick, low-cost profiling and filling gaps between boreholesNo sample; friction effects at depth
Rotary coringContinuous rock core, RQD, recovery, fracturingRock, weathered rock, bouldersSlower and costlier per meter
Vane or pressuremeter testsUndrained strength or deformationSoft clays, specific design inputsSpecialized equipment

How to choose

  1. Start with the design question. Do you need bearing capacity in soil, rock quality, settlement, or the position of the bedrock?
  2. Match the method to the ground. A profile in soft clay suits CPT. Weathered rock or boulders need coring.
  3. Combine methods. A common program uses SPT or DPSH for coverage and a few boreholes with sampling or coring for calibration.
  4. Plan for refusal. If SPT may stop above the depth you need, plan how you will continue. See What is the SPT.

The mixed borehole

A frequent solution is to start in SPT and switch to rotary coring when the test reaches refusal. That tells you whether refusal is a boulder or continuous rock without remobilizing another rig.

Match the design question to the method

Design questionFirst choiceAdd if needed
Bearing capacity of sand or stiff clay, shallow foundationsSPT with samplingDPSH points between boreholes
Settlement of soft clayCPTu plus undisturbed samplesVane tests
Depth and quality of bedrockRotary coringDPSH to map the rockhead between holes
Lateral variability across a large siteDPSH or CPT gridA few SPT boreholes for calibration
Cobbles or boulders in the profileRotary coringProbing only as a screening tool

These are starting points, not rules. The project specification and the local ground model decide the final program.

Write the refusal rule into the program

  • State the refusal criterion (blows and penetration) the investigation will follow, and the standard and edition it comes from.

  • Say what happens at refusal: stop, change to rotary coring, or move to another method.

  • Ask the crew to record the reason for every stop, not just the word "refusal". See how to read an SPT boring log.

Related reading

To compare the two dynamic tests, read DPSH vs SPT: which test to choose and DPSH (ISO 22476-2). For the rock side, see how to describe rock core, RQD and mixed SPT and rotary rigs.

Frequently asked questions

What are the main limits of the SPT?

Low resolution in very soft soils, one reading per meter, distortion from gravel and cobbles, no characterization of intact rock and variable hammer energy between systems and crews.

When should I use CPT instead of SPT?

In soft to medium soils where a continuous profile of resistance and layering is needed. The CPT cannot penetrate dense gravel or rock and does not recover a sample.

Can DPSH replace SPT?

Not alone. DPSH gives a fast, continuous blow-count profile but no sample, so it is normally calibrated against SPT or boreholes on the same site.

What do I do when the SPT reaches refusal?

Follow the refusal criterion of the standard or project, then change method. A mixed rig switches to rotary coring in the same hole to find out whether refusal is a boulder or continuous rock.

For drilling companies

Offering more than one method broadens the jobs you can win. Diamond Drill multifunction rigs run SPT and rotary coring on the same machine, and the rotary range covers deeper coring work.

Need equipment for SPT?

Diamond Drill manufactures drilling rigs. Talk to our technical team and find the right solution for your work.

Need equipment for SPT?

Talk to our technical team.

Request a proposal →Our offices